For CEOs, CFOs and investors
Independent ERP Consultancy UK The right platform, chosen on evidence
Intology's independent ERP consultants run selections that are not paid for by the winning vendor: no reseller commissions, no implementation upsell and no pre-baked shortlist. Senior consultants sit on your side of the table from business case to signed contract, using FIVEPROOF™, Intology's five-stage independent selection method.
An ERP decision commits the business to a platform, a partner and a cost base for the best part of a decade. That is why boards and investors need a selection they can defend when it is tested.
- No vendor commissions
- No implementation bid
- FIVEPROOF™ selection method
01
The question the board is really asking
For the CFO
For the CEO
For the investor
02
What independent actually means at Intology
Much of the ERP advice available in the UK is funded by the vendor that wins. Intology's commercial model is structurally different, and that difference is what makes the recommendation worth paying for.
No reseller relationships
No implementation upsell
Senior practitioners only
Vendor coverage across the stack
03
When an independent ERP consultant earns the fee
ERP decisions rarely start with a wish list. They start with a trigger, and the trigger usually decides how much independent advice is worth.
- 01An acquisition or carve-out leaves you on a parent company's ERP, or running two systems that now need to become one.
- 02Your current platform is approaching the end of its support life, and the incumbent partner's proposal is the only option on the table.
- 03The business has outgrown entry-level accounting software and the finance team is running the company on spreadsheets around it.
- 04A private equity sponsor or lender wants evidence that a material system decision was competitively tested.
- 05A selection is already under way, and the shortlist came from a reseller or an implementation partner with a product to sell.
For a CFO, the question is not the fee for the selection. It is the whole-life cost of the platform you choose, over the years the business will run on it, and whether the board can defend that choice when it is tested.
04
Why ERP selections go wrong
The selection is where the value of the programme is won or lost. These are the four failure modes we see most often when we're called in to assure a live selection.
Vendor-led selections
Requirements written by IT, not the business
TCO that excludes the awkward numbers
Implementation partner picked by the vendor
What a wrong choice costs
- 01Customisation that recreates the old system on a new platform
- 02Licence and partner costs that rise after signature
- 03An implementation partner you cannot hold to account
- 04Years on a platform the business has outgrown
- 05A second selection, and a second programme
An independent selection costs a fraction of living with the wrong platform.
05
FIVEPROOF™: Intology's five-stage ERP selection
FIVEPROOF™: A repeatable, board-defensible process that runs from strategic intent through to signed contract. Stages can be sequenced or compressed, never skipped.
Stage 1
Strategy and readiness
Confirm the case for change, map current and target operating model, and pressure-test ERP readiness across data, processes, governance and capacity. Output: a one-page strategic brief the board will sign. Typically 2 to 3 weeks.
Stage 2
Business case and TCO
Full business case with realistic five to seven year TCO covering licence, infrastructure, integration, data migration, change, training, run costs and partner inflation. Investment committee-ready. Typically 2 to 3 weeks.
Stage 3
Requirements and RFP
Business-led requirements catalogue (functional, non-functional, integration, regulatory) translated into a weighted RFP and scoring rubric. Vendor longlist agreed against objective criteria. Typically 3 to 4 weeks.
Stage 4
Demos, references and due diligence
Scripted, scenario-based demos run against your data and processes. Reference calls with comparable UK clients. Implementation partner DD run separately from the software DD, so you control both. Typically 4 to 6 weeks.
Stage 5
Contract and commercial support
Commercial review of licence terms, SaaS uplifts, support tiers, partner rate cards and SOW. We sit on your side of the table through negotiation and signature. Typically 2 to 4 weeks.
06
Where this has worked
London footwear group
Finance, product lifecycle and HR platform decisions at once, with vendors already pitching. Intology set out an independent target architecture, scored every vendor claim against evidence and ran scripted demonstrations on the group's own processes, so the leadership team is choosing on evidence rather than sales demonstrations.
Read the case studyFamily-owned food retailer
An ageing, heavily customised Sage 200 platform across 36 stores. Intology led the modernisation, removing around £700,000 of technical debt by decommissioning legacy software and customisations, with no disruption to trading.
Read the case studySee all case studies.
07
What you receive at the end
A board-defensible decision pack the audit committee, sponsor or accounting officer can sign off without rework.
- 01Strategic ERP brief and target operating model summary
- 02Investment-grade business case with five to seven year TCO
- 03Weighted requirements catalogue and scoring rubric
- 04Vendor longlist, shortlist and demo evaluation matrix
- 05Reference-call notes and implementation-partner due diligence
- 06Risk register, mobilisation plan and recommended assurance approach
Where the process needs a formal competition, see RFP and RFI consultancy. For finance platforms specifically, see finance system selection. Once the contract is signed, ERP implementation assurance keeps the integrator to the plan, the budget and the date. If a programme is already in trouble, see programme recovery.
08
Who leads the selection
Every ERP selection is led by Richard Keenlyside, Intology's founder, who has 34 years of board-level technology leadership across CIO, CTO, CISO and Transformation Director roles and has sat on the client side of ERP selections and implementations.
Intology works with FTSE-listed companies, PE-backed businesses, mid-market organisations and UK public sector bodies. Over fifteen years we have delivered more than one hundred programmes for over fifty clients.
Are you really vendor-neutral?
Yes. Intology takes no commissions, kickbacks or referral fees from any ERP vendor or implementation partner, and we do not bid for the implementation that follows the selection. That separation is what makes the advice independent.
Which ERP vendors do you cover?
We work across SAP S/4HANA, Oracle Fusion and NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365 Finance & Operations / Business Central, Workday, Infor, IFS, Sage Intacct, Epicor and Unit4, plus the major UK and international implementation partners (Big Four, Accenture, Capgemini, DXC, Hitachi, Columbus, Cooper Software, HSO and others).
How long does an independent ERP selection take?
End-to-end, typically 12 to 18 weeks for a mid-market organisation depending on scope, sites and the number of shortlisted vendors. We can compress it where there's a board deadline, but we won't compress steps that matter (demos, references and TCO).
What size of organisation do you work with?
Mid-market to large enterprise, typically £25m to £2bn revenue or equivalent public sector scale. Including PE portfolio companies, multi-site manufacturers, services businesses, NHS trusts and central government.
Can you run an assurance review on a selection we've already started?
Yes. We're regularly brought in for an independent assurance review on a live selection, to check that the shortlist holds up, the TCO is honest, the demos are testing the right scenarios and that the implementation-partner process isn't being run by the software vendor.
What happens after the selection?
We hand over a fully-documented decision pack and, if you want, stay engaged in an independent programme assurance role through implementation. We will not bid for the implementation work itself, that's the line that keeps the selection trustworthy.
We only need to replace our finance system, not the whole ERP. Do you do that?
Yes. Where the requirement is confined to the finance function, general ledger, consolidation, reporting and FP&A, our finance system selection service runs a shorter, finance-led process, typically 6 to 10 weeks. If the review shows the requirement is genuinely enterprise-wide, we will tell you and run the full ERP selection instead.
What does an independent ERP consultant do?
An independent ERP consultant works only for the buying organisation. They build the business case and five to seven year cost of ownership, turn the business's requirements into a competitive selection, test vendor and implementation partner claims against evidence, and negotiate the contract. Because Intology takes no commission from any vendor and does not bid for the implementation, the recommendation is the one that suits the business, not the one that pays the adviser. For a CFO, the value is a platform decision the board can defend and a contract that does not drift after signature.
Independent advice. No agenda.
Tell us where you are in the ERP decision. In a confidential conversation with a senior Intology consultant, we will tell you honestly whether you need a full selection, a review of a selection already under way, or nothing from us at all.