Intology

FIVEPROOF: the independent selection method

How Intology runs a technology or supplier selection so the board can defend the award.

FIVEPROOF™ is Intology's five-stage method for running an independent RFI, RFP or system selection on the buyer's side of the table. Each stage produces evidence the board can audit, the scoring model is agreed before any supplier sees the requirement, and Intology takes no commission or referral fee from any supplier. It is used for ERP, finance system, managed service and other material technology purchases.

01

Why a board needs a selection method, not just a tender

Most contested awards fail on the evidence, not the outcome. When a selection is challenged, by an investment committee, an auditor, a losing bidder or a new CFO a year later, the question is rarely "was this the best supplier?" It is "can you show how you decided?" A tender pack, a spreadsheet and a set of demonstration notes rarely answer that. FIVEPROOF™ is built so that every decision point leaves a record: what was required, why each supplier was in or out, how each score was reached, and what the contract protects.

02

The five stages

01

Stage 1: Scope the requirement and fix the scoring model

We establish what is actually being bought and who has to live with it. Requirements come from the people doing the work, not from a supplier's feature list, and are weighted by materiality. The evaluation model is agreed and signed off before any supplier sees the requirement, which stops the process being reverse-engineered towards a preferred answer.

Evidence produced: a signed-off requirements set and weighted scoring model.

02

Stage 2: Test the market and qualify the field

We assess the supply market against your requirements, sector, footprint and growth plans, and build a longlist on fit rather than familiarity. Where an RFI is needed, it qualifies suppliers on capability, financial standing, security posture and references, so evaluation effort is spent only on viable options.

Evidence produced: a reasoned longlist and shortlist, with every exclusion recorded.

03

Stage 3: Run the RFP or ITT and score it properly

We write the RFP or ITT, manage clarifications and score responses against the agreed matrix. Every scorer records a rationale, not just a number. Where panel scores diverge materially we moderate the difference rather than averaging it away, because disagreement is usually where the real risk sits.

Evidence produced: moderated scores with a written rationale for every score.

04

Stage 4: Prove it with demonstrations, references and due diligence

Demonstrations run to your scripts and your scenarios, not the supplier's showcase data. Reference calls are with organisations of comparable size and complexity. Commercial, financial and security due diligence runs in parallel, not after the decision. In system selections, implementation partner due diligence runs separately from the software, so you control both.

Evidence produced: scripted demonstration results, reference notes and due diligence findings.

05

Stage 5: Recommend, negotiate and protect the business case

You receive a board-ready recommendation with full-term costs, a risk assessment and a clear statement of what we would do and why, including when the right answer is to stay with the current supplier. We support negotiation from your side of the table and structure the contract so the assumptions behind the business case are protected in it.

Evidence produced: a board paper, a full-term cost model and contract terms mapped to the business case.

03

How FIVEPROOF™ adapts by category

The five stages are fixed. The emphasis is not. Stages can be sequenced or compressed, never skipped.

  • ERP selection: strategy, readiness and a five to seven year total cost of ownership are settled before requirements go to market. independent ERP consultancy
  • Finance system selection: built around how the close, accounts payable and reporting cycle actually run, across every entity in scope. finance system selection consultancy
  • Managed service and supplier RFPs: a formal RFI stage qualifies the market before a full RFP or ITT is issued. independent RFP consultancy

04

What makes it independent

  • 01

    Engaged and paid only by the buyer. No commissions, referral fees or partner margins from any supplier.

  • 02

    The scoring model is agreed before any supplier sees the requirement.

  • 03

    You own every document, score and record afterwards.

  • 04

    We will recommend no change where that is the right answer.

05

Typical timescales

A supplier or finance system selection typically runs six to fourteen weeks from mobilisation to award recommendation, depending on category complexity, the number of suppliers and whether a formal RFI stage is needed. ERP selections, which include strategy and business case work, typically run thirteen to twenty weeks.

06

Who uses it

CEOs, CFOs and boards about to commit to a material technology or service contract; private equity operating partners who need a portfolio company's selection to stand up to investment committee scrutiny; and finance and IT leaders who have inherited a selection already under way.

07

Frequently asked questions

What is FIVEPROOF™?

FIVEPROOF™ is Intology's five-stage independent selection method: scope and scoring, market qualification, RFP or ITT evaluation, proof through demonstrations, references and due diligence, then recommendation and negotiation. Each stage leaves evidence a board can audit.

Is FIVEPROOF™ only for ERP?

No. It is used for ERP, finance systems, managed services, infrastructure and other material technology or supplier purchases. The stages stay the same; the emphasis changes by category.

How long does a FIVEPROOF™ selection take?

Typically six to fourteen weeks for a supplier or finance system selection, and thirteen to twenty weeks for an ERP selection that includes strategy and business case work.

Does Intology take payment from suppliers?

No. Intology is engaged and paid only by the buyer and takes no commission, referral fee or partner margin from any supplier.

Can FIVEPROOF™ be applied to a selection we have already started?

Yes. We review what has been done against the five stages, close the gaps in the evidence and take the process forward from there.

Who owns FIVEPROOF™?

INTOLOGY™ and FIVEPROOF™ are trade marks of Intology Ltd, UK trade mark applications UK00004458347 and UK00004461428.

Going to market on something material?

Talk to us before the requirement goes out. Thirty minutes is usually enough to tell whether an independent process will earn its fee.

Book a call